Notes
Outline
What is Freedom?
Dictionary definition
The condition of being free of restraints
Liberty of the person from slavery, oppression or incarceration
Political independence; possession of civil rights
Exemption from unpleasant or onerous conditions
The capacity to exercise choice; free will
Frankness; boldness…
But, what explains the special radiance and value attached by American culture to the idea of freedom?
Liberty Leading the People
Eugene Delacroix
British Sources of
the American Idea of Freedom
Free Trade and British Power: Spectator 69
Right to Rebel to Protect one’s freedom: John Locke on Revolution
Media Freedom and Spiritual Identity : John Milton’s Areopagitica
Freedom of Speech: Trenchard and Gordon
An Empire of Liberty: Thomson’s “Rule Britannia!”
The Royal Exchange
Free Trade and British Power:
Joseph Addison, Spectator #69
Commerce stitches all of mankind into peaceful communication [while politics brings war]
Thriving private fortunes bring public benefits
Nature’s design: to scatter diverse blessings so as to promote “intercourse and traffic”
By itself England is a barren, but free trade makes all the riches of the world “ours”
“Trade, without enlarging the British territories, has given us a kind of additional empire”
Right to Rebel: the original Contract
State of Nature
A condition of liberty and license
There is no magistrate to judge between men as to the right
A state of insecurity and war, where “might makes right”
The original Contract of the People to form a Civil Society
For the “mutual preservation of their lives, liberties, and estates,” man joins in civil society
Exchange absolute freedom for security and rights under the law
The legislature, represents the people, frames laws for the public good of society; the magistrate and the judges fairly administer the laws
Freedom and Revolution: an invasion of the rights of the citizen
Invading the “property” of the people. Reader 18-19 (221)
Arbitrary power overrides law, subverting government, and justifying revolution Reader, 19 (222)
Not the people, but the rulers, have precipitated a state of war, brought on rebellion. Reader, 20 (226)
How can you fairly refuse the people’s right to defend themselves? Sheep and wolves. Reader 21-22
Milton’s Areopagitica (1644)
Freedom of Speech
What exception is there to the right of freedom of speech? Reader, 23
If “a man cannot call his tongue his own, he can scarce all any thing else his own”; Why?
Why is the doing of “public mischief” and not hearing of it “only the prerogative and felicity of tyranny”
Why will honest magistrates want “their deeds openly examined and publicly scanned”
James Thomson, “Rule Britannia!” (1740)
When Britain first, at Heaven's command,
2         Arose from out the azure main;
3     This was the charter of the land,
4         And guardian angels sung this strain:
5           "Rule, Britannia, rule the waves;
6           Britons never will be slaves."
7       The nations, not so blest as thee,
8         Must, in their turns, to tyrants fall:
9     While thou shalt flourish great and free,
10       The dread and envy of them all. …Reader, 15
An Empire of Liberty
How does this anthem, written by James Thomson in 1740, make articulations between “Britannia” and commerce and the ocean and freedom?
What role does the use of force (for example in the development of a strong navy) play in this articulation?